A conservation easement dispute can involve valuation, legal eligibility, deed terms and substantiation. An independent valuation expert helps counsel assess the appraisal evidence; that work does not replace legal or tax advice or guarantee a deduction.

Define the review question first

Identify the report under review, the relevant valuation date, property interest, intended users and questions counsel needs answered. Distinguish an appraisal review from a new opinion of value and from expert testimony. Each requires an agreed scope, appropriate information and sufficient time.

Examine the evidence behind the valuation

The review can assess highest and best use, development feasibility, the effect of the recorded restrictions, comparable transactions, adjustments and the support for assumptions. Where a before-and-after method is used, both scenarios need credible support. A development concept alone does not demonstrate legally permissible, physically possible and financially feasible use.

  • The signed appraisal and supporting exhibits
  • The easement deed, amendments, maps and ownership information
  • Zoning, approvals and evidence relevant to development potential
  • Comparable transaction records and verification
  • IRS correspondence and counsel’s identified valuation questions
  • Relevant deadlines and the requested review or testimony deliverables

Keep expert analysis independent

Global Valuation’s focus in disputed easement matters is independent review and expert-witness support. A reviewer should identify both strengths and limitations rather than advocate a predetermined value. Whether the expert signed the original appraisal or reviewed it later does not by itself establish credibility.

Thomas G. Spears holds the ASA and MRICS designations. Appropriate qualifications, applicable standards and jurisdiction-specific requirements should be confirmed for the particular engagement. A court determines admissibility and the weight given to expert evidence.

Coordinate with counsel before deadlines

Early assessment can reveal missing records and analytical questions that require further investigation. Testimony, rebuttal analysis and a new valuation are separate deliverables to discuss rather than assume are included in a review fee. No appraisal can guarantee an IRS or court outcome.

Read the IRS conservation easement guidance and our conservation easement practice overview.

Discuss your appraisal requirements

Share the property location, asset type, intended use, valuation date and deadline. We will discuss the scope and information needed before proposing an assignment.

Request a confidential consultationExplore related services

Why discuss easement-related valuation with Global Valuation?

An easement assignment starts with the actual property rights, restrictions and intended use of the appraisal. Global Valuation offers conservation-easement appraisal services; an initial discussion helps establish the proposed scope and the supporting documents needed for review.

Why request a consultation? Bring the location, relevant instruments, intended users and deadline. A consultation helps separate valuation questions from legal or tax advice, which should come from your advisers. No deduction, agency acceptance or transaction outcome is promised.

Led by Thomas G. Spears, ASA, MRICS, Global Valuation focuses on commercial and specialty real estate. Our team reviews the initial inquiry and organizes the assignment details for Mr. Spears. You can review Thomas G. Spears's credentials, the firm's assignment information and related appraisal services before getting in touch.

Request an appraisal consultation

Start with a brief overview; please do not send confidential documents through the initial form. Assignment acceptance, scope, fee and timing are confirmed separately after review.